I’m biased, but I feel he has missed the point in comparing iWork 08 with Microsoft Office for the Mac.
iWork is quite clearly targeted at a different audience to the full version of office; in fact I am the target audience.
I want a word processor, spreadsheet and presentation package and nothing else.
I want those packages to have OS X like elegance and to enable me to carry the relatively basic writing and calculating that most users need to do. Numbers, the new spreadsheet application doesn’t do pivot tables apparently – what’s a pivot table?
Personally I couldn’t wait to remove Office from my Macs and to replace it with iWork and so far it does everything that I need and more.