As an ex-Psion employee I was disappointed and a little saddened to learn of Psion’s spurious trademark claim to the word netbook. Psion were once a great technology company practically inventing the PDA , creating some classic hardware designs and creating the operating system that powers a huge proporation of today’s smartphones: Symbian.
Psion launched the Psion netBook (also badged a Series 7) in 1999. The netBook was a sub-notebook running Psion’s EPOC operating system and discontinued in 2003.
I remember playing with a pre-production netBook giving my feedback as to how I felt the EPOC OS should be adapted to work on the bigger screen and thinking we had a very cool device here. Psion used external design consultants Therefore for their hardware design, and the netBook was another triumph of industrial design.
As with the Series 3 and 5 PDAs that preceded it the netBook had a clever hinge that made the device seem to grow as you opened it revealing a keyboard that seemed larger than it should be. The hinge itself was wrapped in leather so it felt like carrying a leather book or Filofax. As well as an almost full size keyboard the netBook had a touch screen and solid state internals. Writing this now I realise that the Psion netBook really was ahead of it’s time.
A few years ago I bumped into an old colleague who showed me a netBook running Linux pre-dating the Eee PC and co. by some years. Sadly Psion didn’t release this version in yet another moment of corporate short-sightedness and cowardice.
Palm chickened out of the two hottest personal technology markets despite having a massive head start on the competition. I was fortunate to see the designs and concepts for a range of smartphones Psion were working on but ultimately didn’t develop. Then of course Psion pulled out of the PDA market saying they couldn’t beat Palm.
Psion are now a pale imitation of the once great innovators they were; based in Canada Psion Teklogix now produce rugged industrial handheld computers. So their decision to claim the netbook trademark and to threaten websites, resellers and IT manufacturers with legal action felt like the last dieing actions of once great brand.
Shame on you Psion.
But well done Dell for challenging this ridiculous claim; it looks like game over for Psion before they’ve even started.
Update: Dell have accused Psion of “fraudulently” claiming the trademark netbook was still in use.
Note: I was also amazed to see that design of the Psion Teklogix site is largely the same as the one I left behind when I left Psion in 2000 and it was out of date then.
What we just couldn’t understand was why they didn’t just dust off the old netBook blueprints, refresh the OS and [re]release the thing as the “world’s first and best netbook”, proclaiming themselves to be a decade ahead of the competition? It’s not too late, but they’re already taking an absolute beating over this scandal and now have the added stigma of purgery by a senior employee.
Furthermore they’ve pissed off just about every netbook related site (some of them down thousands of dollars in lost advertising revenue) so I would’t be liking my chances of getting a positive review if they were to revive the product.
The device looks (and sounds) great, but with a $1,299 pricetag and no supporting cloud computing infrastructure it’s no surprise it was a stillborn. It wouldn’t even fall into the “netbook” category they’re claiming to have created.
Anyway thanks for your insightful and heartfelt post,
Cheers,
Save the Netbooks
Thanks.
I couldn’t agree more. The hardware design was great; it just needed updating and a modern OS or even an updated version of EPOC/Symbian (although probably not possible) it would have been awesome.
Hi David!
Nice article, but to be exact:
The image above shows a Psion Teklogix Netbook PRO with Windows CE 4.2., which was available til mid of 2006 (beginning of RoHS). The Psion LX (with a special Linux distribution) was based on a Netbook pro with larger RAM. And Psion was very late given intels Netbook start was around march 2008. But rights should be equal for all IMHO.
And to Save the Netbooks:
The original EPOC netBook idea was really far ahead of its time (it was GSM/GPRS time!) and all the young netbook sites ‘losing thousands of dollar ad money’ should remember that every development always has a ingenius and original starting point, and this cheap xp-notebooks are by far not the spearhead of our technology now. They are indeed a downsizing design by intel to have a foot in the door against the OLPC initiative. Latter was a genius idea with large media coverage worldwide.
What worries me a bit is the clever 200€ ‘Linux-Netbook’ versions are not so successful than the boring 3-400€ xp variants… Bread and games for the masses…
Cheers
Tom
PW
@Tom
Thanks for your comments.
The image is really just to show what the netBook looked like; I simply Googled Psion netBook and chose that one as it looked nice :-)
The Linux version I saw was definitely aimed at consumers using a “user friendly” version of Linux. The conversation I had with my ex-colleague suggested they were evaluating it for possible consumer release.
With regard to you concern over Xp outselling Linux – I’m pretty tech savvy and have used many computers and OS over the years. I had a Linux Eee PC and gave up, swapping it for an XP version, as Linux is just too difficult. If I find it difficult then 99% of the netbook market are going to find it REALLY difficult.
What we really need is a netbook running OS X – a MacBook Mini. Now that will be the machine to have.
> What we really need is a netbook running OS X – a MacBook Mini.
> Now that will be the machine to have.
Hi David,
I have an Acer Aspire One (yes, one of those €200 things) with EPOC running on it!
OK, to be precise it has Linux on it with the EPOC emulator running under Wine. But it was easy to install, as I showed in my video podcast at the weekend: http://tinyurl.com/d754jc
Regards,
Graham
Hmm not sure an EPOC emulator running on Linux is a step forward ;-)
Now an updated version of EPOC with instant on etc. would be very interesting. Imagine the EPOC app store to add new apps :-)
Is your own bias showing through here? ,
Of course my bias is showing; it’s my blog and hence stuffed to the gills with my bias :)
The main thrust of my post was sadness and disappointment that Psion had such a great opportunity and product but ultimately chickened out. iPhone, Google Nexus One both of these devices could have been playuing catch up to Psion if they had continued their great work.